Back to Blog

Cheap Cars That Are Expensive to Own

Cheap cars that are expensive to own in the US—high depreciation, repair cost, or insurance. How to spot them and compare total cost.

AutoPremo Team
January 31, 2026
2 min read

A "cheap" car in the U.S. can be expensive to own—high depreciation, repair cost, or insurance can make total cost higher than a pricier car. Here's how to spot cheap cars that are expensive to own and how to compare total cost.

TL;DR Cheap to buy ≠ cheap to own. Compare total cost of ownership—purchase + depreciation + fuel + insurance + maintenance—over 5 years. Use autopremo.com total cost of ownership to see which cars are cheap to own, not just cheap to buy.

Why "Cheap" Cars Can Be Expensive to Own

  • High depreciation — a cheap car that loses 60% of value in 5 years can cost more in depreciation (as % of purchase) than a car that holds value.
  • High repair cost — some cheap used cars have known reliability issues; repair cost can exceed the car's value.
  • High insurance — some "cheap" cars (sporty, high-theft) have high insurance; total cost can be higher than a "pricier" car with lower insurance.
  • Poor fuel economy — cheap older cars can have bad MPG; fuel cost over 5 years can be high.
See total cost at autopremo.com.

How to Spot Them

  • Check total cost of ownership — use autopremo.com total cost of ownership. Compare cheap-to-buy cars to pricier cars over 5 years. If total cost is higher for the "cheap" car, it's expensive to own.
  • Check reliability and repair cost — research the exact year and model; factor repair risk into total cost.
  • Get insurance quotes — before you buy, get a quote for that vehicle. High insurance can make a "cheap" car expensive to own.
Compare total cost at autopremo.com.

Bottom Line

Cheap to buy doesn't mean cheap to own. Compare total cost of ownership—not just sticker—over 5 years. Use autopremo.com to see which cars are cheap to own so you don't overpay over time.

Share this article